Everyone has experienced a disappointing remake of a favourite film; while we always hope for an improvement, only occasionally do we get one. Board games have a similar problem, but as with films, things are often not clear cut. For example, the new version of Camel Up arguably has nicer art and a better pyramid dice shaker than the original. The Crazy Camel mini expansion and the partnership betting (from the original Supercup expansion) also add quite a bit to the game play, especially at higher player counts, but the money isn’t as easy to handle and the dice and camels themselves are plastic and don’t feel as nice.
|– Image by boardGOATS|
Similarly, the recent editions of Glen More (Glen More II: Chronicles) and Snowdonia (the Deluxe Master set) are beautiful and include lots of extra content. As previously discussed, this is at the expense of shelf-space though, and portability which means they are less likely to get played. In other cases, the revision is considered a definite step back. For example, the revised edition of Colosseum by TMG is widely believed to compare unfavourably with the original Days of Wonder edition.
|– Image by boardGOATS|
In a recent new edition of Monopoly, female players initially receive $1,900 with a salary of $240, while male players start with $1,500 receiving $200 when they pass “Go”. On the plus-side, as part of the publicity, three teenage entrepreneurs received a grant of $20,580 each to invest in their own inventions. Otherwise, Ms Monopoly is widely thought to be hugely patronising to half the population while claiming to celebrate empowering women, something that is apparent in the adverts.
|– Video by Hasbro on youtube.com|
These days, a lot of gaming is being done online. One new electronic game that has been seen as a retrograde step is the new Scrabble app, Scrabble Go. This is a new product that, thanks to changes in licensing, replaces the previous offering from Electronic Arts (EA). The problem is that the new version seems to have been designed to appeal to the Candy Crush generation with vivid colours, treasure-style rewards and in-app purchases. Unfortunately, Scrabble is a very traditional game and its players generally don’t appreciate that approach. To date, nearly eight thousand of these have registered their disgust through an online petition.
|– Image by boardGOATS from play.google.com|
The Carcassonne app has also received a similar licensing-inspired change and although the new Asmodee version is less offensive, many seem to prefer the older, Coding Monkeys version. So, before deciding to upgrade a game, keep in mind that a new version, often isn’t a better one.